72

News

Hospital “weekend effect” a myth

admin
February 9th, 2015


This article is more than 9 years old.

No greater risk of dying in hospitals on weekends than on weekdays, research shows

Contrary to the findings of earlier studies, the chances of dying in hospital do not increase if a patient is admitted over a weekend, at least not if their condition involves a stroke or blood clot. 

Researchers from Syddansk University looked at 65,000 Danish patients who were admitted to Danish hospitals between 2003 and 2011 with a stroke or blood clot in the brain, concluding that the risk of a patient dying does not increase if they are admitted to the hospital on a Saturday or Sunday rather than a Wednesday.

Adjusting the numbers
“Raw figures indicate that patients admitted at weekends die at a higher rate than those admitted during regular hours,” Nina Sahlertz Kristiansen, who led the research, told Politiken.

“But when the numbers are adjusted to reflect that patients admitted over the weekend are often more seriously ill than those who are hospitalised throughout the week, the mortality rate equalises.”

Kristiansen said the mortality rate of patients with maladies other that blood clots on the brain or strokes may well be higher.

The 'weekend effect' debate flared up last August when the head doctor at a clinic in Helsingør published a study pointing to a higher weekend mortality rate.

READ MORE: Mortality rate in hospitals twice as high on weekends and holidays

Cautious optimism
At that time, Mads Koch Hansen, the head of the doctors' group Lægeforeningen, called for changes to the system.

But now Hansen says the latest figures show the changes are working.

“At least in this area, it appears we are doing better,” Hansen told Politiken. “We have focused on stoke patients and established acute care procedures that have helped.”

Patient organisation Danske Patienter expressed cautious optimism at the results of the study.

“If it is true things are improving for weekend and after-hours patients, then that is great,” said Danske Patienter head Morten Freil.

“But this is just one study, and other studies have shown different results, so a follow-up is needed.”


Share

Most popular

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up to receive The Daily Post

















Latest Podcast

A survey carried out by Megafon for TV2 has found that 71 percent of parents have handed over children to daycare in spite of them being sick.

Moreover, 21 percent of those surveyed admitted to medicating their kids with paracetamol, such as Panodil, before sending them to school.

The FOLA parents’ organisation is shocked by the findings.

“I think it is absolutely crazy. It simply cannot be that a child goes to school sick and plays with lots of other children. Then we are faced with the fact that they will infect the whole institution,” said FOLA chair Signe Nielsen.

Pill pushers
At the Børnehuset daycare institution in Silkeborg a meeting was called where parents were implored not to bring their sick children to school.

At Børnehuset there are fears that parents prefer to pack their kids off with a pill without informing teachers.

“We occasionally have children who that they have had a pill for breakfast,” said headteacher Susanne Bødker. “You might think that it is a Panodil more than a vitamin pill, if it is a child who has just been sick, for example.”

Parents sick and tired
Parents, when confronted, often cite pressure at work as a reason for not being able to stay at home with their children.

Many declare that they simply cannot take another day off, as they are afraid of being fired.

Allan Randrup Thomsen, a professor of virology at KU, has heavily criticised the parents’ actions, describing the current situation as a “vicious circle”.

“It promotes the spread of viruses, and it adds momentum to a cycle where parents are pressured by high levels of sick-leave. If they then choose to send the children to daycare while they are still recovering, they keep the epidemic going in daycares, and this in turn puts a greater burden on the parents.”